Credit Card Sign-Up Bonus Gluttony: Probably Not a Viable Travel Rewards Strategy for Most of Us

Frank McBride • February 2, 2024

Rapid fire card applications could bring potential credit issues

A couple of weeks ago, Gary Leff of the View from the Wing blog, wrote about how he applied, and received instant approval, for five credit cards over the course of a weekend. The cards – four business cards and one personal card – will yield him 460,000 bonus points and miles (or around 500,000 when including the points and miles he will earn for the spending needed to reach the bonus thresholds).


The cards that will soon appear in Gary’s mailbox are:


  • The American Express Business Platinum card – He gets 150,000 Membership Rewards points after spending $15,000 in the first three months.
  • Chase INK Preferred Business card – 100,000 Ultimate Rewards points after spending $8,000 in the first three months.
  • CitiBusiness Advantage Platinum Selection Mastercard – 65,000 American miles after spending $4,000 in the first four months.
  • Alaska Airlines Visa Business card – 75,000 Alaska miles after spending $4,000 in the first three months.
  • Alaska Airlines Visa card – 70,000 Alaska miles after spending $3,000 in the first three months.


The clock for spending enough to meet a card’s bonus threshold starts as soon as you are approved (not when you receive the card in the mail and activate it). Some quick math shows that Mr. Leff needs to put $34,000 on his new credit cards in the next three months to get all those bonuses.
 
View from the Wing is a popular travel blog, and I am sure Leff is good for the minimum spend and then some. However, I do not believe that this approach is feasible for most people. There is the high level of spending in a brief period of time, of course. And the total annual fees for these five cards will approach $1100.
 
A greater concern could be the impact that moves like this could have on most Americans’ credit ratings and their relationships with banks. Leff was smart to apply for all these cards at about the same time and to spread his applications out among four card issuers -- Amex, Chase, Citi (American Airlines), and Bank of America (Alaska Airlines). But, a credit card application generates a “hard pull” with credit reporting agencies and banks get nervous when they see an applicant who has applied for multiple sources of credit in a short period of time. Perhaps Leff applied for the five cards faster than information about his “hard pulls” could appear on credit reports and the different banks did not know what was afoot. I would be interested in knowing how his bold move will affect his FICO score going forward as well as his ability to pick up his next credit card.


Points and miles blogs have lots of interesting and entertaining anecdotes but much of what the bloggers do and write about is impractical for most Americans. The Travel Rewards Optimizer plans we create are designed to fit with our clients’ routine spending so that they can have a predictable, reliable, and sustainable source of free and reduced cost travel for years to come. 



We are ready to help you turn your routine credit card spending into the travel of your dreams.

By Frank McBride • November 20, 2026
The Chase World of Hyatt credit card has a $95 annual fee, confers “Discoverist” status on World of Hyatt members, and accelerates members’ accumulation of Hyatt points when staying in Hyatt properties. My favorite feature is that this card gives you one free night at each cardmember anniversary that can be used for a Category 1-4 property (Hyatt properties are classified into eight categories). Because that one free night is worth more than the annual cost of the card, this card is a no brainer if you know you will use the free room. This card’s sign-up bonus (SUB) varies from time to time. Until recently, the bonus was 30,000 Hyatt points after spending $3,000 within the first three months. The bonus could increase to 60,000 points with a total spend of $15,000 during the first six months of membership. The most recent SUB is four free nights in Hyatt’s Category 1-4 properties after spending $5,000 within three months. This card seems to switch back and forth between offering Hyatt points and free rooms but, for many travelers, the free rooms might be the better deal for someone considering this card. Let’s look at the value of the two SUBs that are frequently offered and what you must spend to get them. World of Hyatt Points Various points and miles websites give values for Hyatt points that range from 1.5 to 2.4 cents per point. Based on my experience, I tend to get about 2.5 cents of value per point for domestic (US) stays and 1.5 cents per point for stays at European properties. For the SUBs of 30,000 or 60,000 points, the best-case scenario would be total values of $750 or $1500. The first $750 would require spending $3,000, and the cardholder would need to spend an additional $12,000 to push the SUB’s value to $1500. Four Free Rooms at Category 1-4 Properties Hyatt has eight categories of properties and the four free room awards need to be used at properties falling into the lower four categories (1-4). You will not be staying in the Park Hyatt Paris-Vendome or the all-inclusive Hyatt resorts with these free room awards. However, there is still considerable value even in these more midscale Hyatt brands. Ms. Optimizer and I both hold this World of Hyatt credit card and have been able to use our annual free room award (also limited to Hyatt categories 1-4) to stay in rooms that would otherwise go for $400 to $600 per night. Even sticking with the low end of this range, these four free nights can yield $1600 in value against a bonus threshold spend of $5,000. Bottom Line From a purely dollars and cents angle, the free rooms would be the best bet for most people. The only downside I see is that, once the four rooms are awarded, they come with a 12-month expiration date. You must not only book a room or rooms with them, but also complete the stay, before these expiration dates. To the best of my knowledge, those expiration dates cannot be extended. The Hyatt points, on the other hand, do not expire for two years and their expiration can be extended with any World of Hyatt activity. Bear in mind that the four free nights do not have to be used together. They can also be combined with room purchases made in points or cash. In fact, a favorite hack is to use these free nights when a reservation covers multiple nights with different nightly rates (Ex: a three-day weekend). We have used free night awards for more expensive Friday and Saturday nights while paying in cash for the less expensive Sunday night. The offers made by travel-oriented credit card issuers change constantly. When we create a custom Travel Rewards Optimizer plan for a client, we take all the latest information and offers into account so that you can get to your next vacation as soon as possible. We are ready to help you turn your routine credit card spending into the travel of your dreams.
By Frank McBride • November 10, 2026
Two or more household members can work together to accelerate award travel
By Frank McBride • September 21, 2026
Chase is about to devalue Chase UR point to World of Hyatt point transfers
By Frank McBride • September 4, 2026
In case you missed them, here is your "one-stop shopping" for posts from the past week. For some, recent changes with the Resy restaurant reservation platform might limit dining options when using the credit. Learn more here . Perhaps your next US domestic award flight should be booked through . . . Air France. Check out why . The Amex Platinum card might have the highest annual fee for mass marketed cards. Find out if the benefits are worth it for my household here . Hope you have a great Labor Day weekend!! We are ready to help you turn your routine credit card spending into the travel of your dreams.
By Frank McBride • September 3, 2026
A walk through one household's use of the Amex Platinum card
By Frank McBride • August 28, 2026
For some domestic flights, Air France might save transferable miles
By Frank McBride • August 27, 2026
Recent changes in the Resy reservations platform might limit use of the Amex dining credit
By Frank McBride • June 25, 2026
Changes are a mixed bag but Hyatt regulars won't be happy
By Frank McBride • June 5, 2026
Some good news in points and miles (and one warning)
By Frank McBride • May 29, 2026
A change in favor of airline passengers (for a change)