How Much Return Can You Expect from Your Points and Miles Portfolio?

Frank McBride • January 19, 2024

Part III of a three-part series on the Points and Miles "Portfolio"

This is the third part of a three-part series “Your Points and Miles ‘Portfolio.’” On Monday, I discussed key principles for building and protecting your points and miles portfolio. Yesterday, the focus was on evaluating the portfolio. Today’s post will discuss how to assess the “return” of your portfolio.


The previous posts in this series have discussed the idea of seeing your points and miles as you might see an investment portfolio, the principles for creating this portfolio, and an approach to determining its value.


The last piece will focus on the idea of the return on your points and miles. With an investment portfolio, you want to see growth, even if you are not adding funds to it. A points and miles “portfolio” can grow simply because you are spending money with credit cards.


While growth is a given, the actual return – what you are getting in travel value relative to the amount you are spending on your credit cards – is what matters. Greater return means that you are getting more free or reduced cost travel from your routine spending. But return is also important from the standpoint that credit cards can have annual fees and you need to spend at least a little time keeping up with your points and miles.


There are cards that do not have annual fees that can generate a two percent return so, if you are paying annual fees, you definitely want to see a return that is appreciably better than two percent.

 
This is the formula I use to determine my return:

 
                                        FMV of Travel + Value of Benefits –  Annual Card Fees – Interest/other fees

                 Return =                ____________________________________________________________________

                                                                  Total amount of spending put on credit cards

Where:


  • FMV of Travel = the fair market value (actual price) you would pay in cash for the flight or hotel room at the time you make a redemption minus any taxes or fees you may have to pay that are not covered by the redemption. (Ex: With airline ticket redemptions, you must pay a TSA fee of $5.60 per one-way ticket/$11.20 round trip. There are also taxes and fees you cannot avoid when using miles for international travel.).


  • Value of Benefits = perks, discounts, etc. that are offered by a credit card. These can include: checked bag fees, food vouchers, lounge access, and Global Entry/TSA Pre-check application fees.


  • Annual Card Fees = Annual membership fees that are not optional. This would include authorized user fees which can be assessed for cards offering premium benefits.


  • Interest/other fees = interest charged if you carry a balance, late fees, fees for exceeding your credit limit, and other fees that should be avoided. (If you tend to carry a balance, interest charges could wipe out any value you are getting from your program and you should be looking for credit cards with the lowest rates.)


Again, if you are interested in travel rewards, you should be getting more than the two percent return you can get with a simple (and free) cashback card. Otherwise, there is no reason to pursue travel rewards. But, eight years of experience has shown me that if you want to travel, travel rewards deliver considerable value beyond that two percent.


When I ran this return calculation for Ms. Optimizer and myself, our 2023 return came out to 10.8 percent. In other words, for every dollar we spent last year on a credit card, we got about 11 cents back in travel value.


I would add a couple of important points.


  • For my calculation, I did NOT include any benefits (checked baggage fees, upgrades, Uber discounts, lounge visits, etc.) in my calculation. They tend to be many small amounts that are hard to price individually but they do add up. I would estimate that, if included, they would increase our return beyond 11 percent.


  • We tend to grab at least two sign-up bonuses (SUB) between us each year. We only took advantage of one last year, so we were not relying on multiple SUBs to boost our return.

 

  • In case you were wondering, these returns in the form of free travel are not taxable. Because you are spending money to get the points, including the large new cardmember bonuses, your points and miles are considered rebates, not taxable income or gifts.

 

Obviously, if we create a Travel Rewards Optimizer plan for you, we cannot guarantee any specific amount of return. However, we are confident that the travel value you receive will easily exceed the flat fee we charge for your TRO plan.


Whether you choose to ever use our services or not, I hope this week’s three-part series has demonstrated the potential of points and miles. With regards to travel, it has been a game changer for me and my clients.
 

We are ready to help you turn your routine credit card spending into the travel of your dreams.



By Frank McBride • November 20, 2026
The Chase World of Hyatt credit card has a $95 annual fee, confers “Discoverist” status on World of Hyatt members, and accelerates members’ accumulation of Hyatt points when staying in Hyatt properties. My favorite feature is that this card gives you one free night at each cardmember anniversary that can be used for a Category 1-4 property (Hyatt properties are classified into eight categories). Because that one free night is worth more than the annual cost of the card, this card is a no brainer if you know you will use the free room. This card’s sign-up bonus (SUB) varies from time to time. Until recently, the bonus was 30,000 Hyatt points after spending $3,000 within the first three months. The bonus could increase to 60,000 points with a total spend of $15,000 during the first six months of membership. The most recent SUB is four free nights in Hyatt’s Category 1-4 properties after spending $5,000 within three months. This card seems to switch back and forth between offering Hyatt points and free rooms but, for many travelers, the free rooms might be the better deal for someone considering this card. Let’s look at the value of the two SUBs that are frequently offered and what you must spend to get them. World of Hyatt Points Various points and miles websites give values for Hyatt points that range from 1.5 to 2.4 cents per point. Based on my experience, I tend to get about 2.5 cents of value per point for domestic (US) stays and 1.5 cents per point for stays at European properties. For the SUBs of 30,000 or 60,000 points, the best-case scenario would be total values of $750 or $1500. The first $750 would require spending $3,000, and the cardholder would need to spend an additional $12,000 to push the SUB’s value to $1500. Four Free Rooms at Category 1-4 Properties Hyatt has eight categories of properties and the four free room awards need to be used at properties falling into the lower four categories (1-4). You will not be staying in the Park Hyatt Paris-Vendome or the all-inclusive Hyatt resorts with these free room awards. However, there is still considerable value even in these more midscale Hyatt brands. Ms. Optimizer and I both hold this World of Hyatt credit card and have been able to use our annual free room award (also limited to Hyatt categories 1-4) to stay in rooms that would otherwise go for $400 to $600 per night. Even sticking with the low end of this range, these four free nights can yield $1600 in value against a bonus threshold spend of $5,000. Bottom Line From a purely dollars and cents angle, the free rooms would be the best bet for most people. The only downside I see is that, once the four rooms are awarded, they come with a 12-month expiration date. You must not only book a room or rooms with them, but also complete the stay, before these expiration dates. To the best of my knowledge, those expiration dates cannot be extended. The Hyatt points, on the other hand, do not expire for two years and their expiration can be extended with any World of Hyatt activity. Bear in mind that the four free nights do not have to be used together. They can also be combined with room purchases made in points or cash. In fact, a favorite hack is to use these free nights when a reservation covers multiple nights with different nightly rates (Ex: a three-day weekend). We have used free night awards for more expensive Friday and Saturday nights while paying in cash for the less expensive Sunday night. The offers made by travel-oriented credit card issuers change constantly. When we create a custom Travel Rewards Optimizer plan for a client, we take all the latest information and offers into account so that you can get to your next vacation as soon as possible. We are ready to help you turn your routine credit card spending into the travel of your dreams.
By Frank McBride • November 10, 2026
Two or more household members can work together to accelerate award travel
By Frank McBride • September 21, 2026
Chase is about to devalue Chase UR point to World of Hyatt point transfers
By Frank McBride • September 4, 2026
In case you missed them, here is your "one-stop shopping" for posts from the past week. For some, recent changes with the Resy restaurant reservation platform might limit dining options when using the credit. Learn more here . Perhaps your next US domestic award flight should be booked through . . . Air France. Check out why . The Amex Platinum card might have the highest annual fee for mass marketed cards. Find out if the benefits are worth it for my household here . Hope you have a great Labor Day weekend!! We are ready to help you turn your routine credit card spending into the travel of your dreams.
By Frank McBride • September 3, 2026
A walk through one household's use of the Amex Platinum card
By Frank McBride • August 28, 2026
For some domestic flights, Air France might save transferable miles
By Frank McBride • August 27, 2026
Recent changes in the Resy reservations platform might limit use of the Amex dining credit
By Frank McBride • June 25, 2026
Changes are a mixed bag but Hyatt regulars won't be happy
By Frank McBride • June 5, 2026
Some good news in points and miles (and one warning)
By Frank McBride • May 29, 2026
A change in favor of airline passengers (for a change)